Skip to main content

Sensitivity of silicon-to-water dose conversion and Bragg-peak metrics to stopping-power datasets in proton dosimetry

In brief

Stopping-power datasets change proton dose estimates up to 2.1%, not peak depth

In simulations of a 67.5 MeV proton beam, stopping-power choices changed converted dose by about 3% across the entrance and plateau, and by up to 2.1% near the Bragg peak. Converted curves placed the peak at the same depth, but direct simulations differed, with only one matching the experimental uncertainty. The findings underscore the need to align datasets or account for their effects in dose uncertainty.

Journal
Physics in medicine and biology (Q1)
Published
20 November 2026
Study design
Unclassified
Evidence level
Level 5, Expert Opinion (CEBM 5)
Authors
Flávio Matias da Silva, Julian Shorto, Pablo de Vera, Rafael Garcia-Molina, Isabel Abril, T F Silva, et al.
PMID
43063612
DOI
10.1088/1361-6560/aec531

Why clinicians should know about it

  • Picked for Medical Physics (top studies of the week, 22 November 2026): Stopping-power dataset effects on proton detector dose conversion

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Accurate proton dosimetry requires internally consistent stopping-power data for
detector-to-water dose conversion and Monte Carlo radiation transport simulations. This study
quantifies how water-to-silicon stopping-power ratios, converted dose-to-water distributions,
and Bragg-peak metrics vary with the stopping-power dataset for a 67.5 MeV pristine proton
beam in water. APPROACH: PHITS simulations were performed using dataset-specific stopping
powers from SRIM-2013, PSTAR/NIST, ATIMA, and TDDFT-Penn for proton energies
up to 10 MeV, combined with a common SBETHE-based high-energy extension above
10 MeV. Normalized percentage depth-ionization data from the PTW silicon diode in the
published benchmark of Faddegon et al. (2015) were converted into relative percentage depth-
dose distributions in water using depth-dependent water-to-silicon stopping-power ratios.
Direct dose-to-water simulations were performed to evaluate Bragg-peak and distal-range
metrics. MAIN RESULTS: The water-to-silicon stopping-power ratio exhibited a pronounced
depth dependence, with relative entrance-to-distal variations ranging from 17.40% to 22.10%
across the datasets. All converted relative PDD curves reached their maximum at 36.86 mm,
with no dataset-dependent shift. This position agrees with the experimental Bragg-peak
depth of (36.81 ± 0.15) mm, defined as the midpoint between adjacent PDI maxima at 36.76
and 36.86 mm. The converted curves were approximately 3% below the reference curve
throughout the entrance and plateau regions, while dataset-dependent deviations of up to
2.1% were observed near the Bragg peak. Direct PHITS calculations predicted Bragg-peak
depths ranging from 36.575 to 36.675 mm; only the TDDFT-Penn result lay within the quoted
experimental uncertainty. SIGNIFICANCE: For this benchmark, the stopping-power treatment
affects the normalization of the converted dose throughout the entrance, plateau, and distal
regions more strongly than it affects the Bragg-peak position. Harmonizing stopping-power
data between detector-to-water conversion and Monte Carlo transport, or explicitly including
dataset dependence in the uncertainty budget, is important for proton-beam calibration,
commissioning, quality assurance, and Monte Carlo validation.

Abstract as published, via PubMed.

View on PubMedFull text at the publisherOpen in the app

For healthcare professionals. The summary is generated by AI from the published abstract, and the evidence level is assigned automatically from the study design on the Oxford CEBM hierarchy. Neither is medical advice. Read the full paper before changing practice.