Skip to main content

Factors determining the effectiveness of audit & feedback on clinical guideline adherence of hospital-based medical specialists: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

In brief

Audit and feedback raises specialists' guideline-adherence odds by 30%

Across 17 comparisons, audit and feedback was linked to 30% higher odds of guideline adherence than no intervention; across eight comparisons, odds were 60% higher than with another intervention. The overall finding supports audit and feedback, but many studies had risk of bias, and effects varied across clinical topics and hospitals, leaving unclear which approach works best in each setting.

Journal
Implementation science : IS (Q1)
Published
19 August 2026
Study design
Systematic review / meta-analysis of RCTs
Evidence level
Level 1, High (CEBM 1a)
Authors
Vera de Weerdt, Juliëtte J C M van Munster, Ilan J Y Halperin, Hanna C Willems, Madelon van Wely, Joost G Daams, et al.
PMID
43040368
DOI
10.1186/s13012-026-01513-3

Why clinicians should know about it

  • Picked for Health Informatics (top studies of the week, 22 November 2026): Meta-analysis evaluates feedback effects on clinical guideline adherence

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Audit & Feedback (A&F) is a common intervention to enhance clinical guideline adherence, yet uncertainty remains regarding the factors influencing its effectiveness. OBJECTIVE: To examine the effectiveness of A&F interventions targeting clinical guideline adherence of hospital-based medical specialists in general and to determine which design characteristics, co-interventions and contextual factors explain variance in A&F effectiveness. METHODS: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials was conducted following the Cochrane Handbook methodology. The electronic databases MEDLINE, Embase and Web of Science were searched up to January 2024. Two reviewers independently screened articles and selected studies on A&F interventions targeting clinical guideline adherence of hospital-based medical specialists. Risk of bias was assessed by two independent reviewers, following the ROB2 tools. Data on design characteristics, co-interventions, contextual factors and outcomes were extracted by one reviewer and checked by a second reviewer. Results were described descriptively and when appropriate meta-analysis and subgroup analyses using random effects modelling was performed. RESULTS: Forty-one studies were included. Studies had a 2-armed (N = 35), 3-armed (N = 5) or 2 × 2 (N = 1) design and compared A&F vs. no intervention (N = 15), A&F vs. another intervention (N = 8) or A&F vs. A&F (N = 20). Studies targeted 23 different medical specialties, of which Cardiology (N = 8), General Medicine (N = 7), ICU (N = 6) and Emergency Care (N = 6) were most targeted. Risk of bias was low in six studies, with some risk in 19 studies and high risk in 16 studies. Meta-analysis showed a significant improvement of clinical guideline adherence due to A&F, with a pooled OR of 1.30 (95% CI of 1.12-1.50), I2 = 57.8%, N = 17 comparisons) for A&F vs. no intervention and 1.60 (95% CI 1.38-1.84, I2 = 8.6%, N = 8 comparisons) for A&F vs. another intervention. Studies examining the effectiveness of A&F interventions showed similar effect sizes, while the variation across studies in types of design characteristics, co-interventions and context was large. Subgroup analyses for design characteristics only showed significant differences if one high risk study was included. Large variation in co-interventions and poor reporting of context factors precluded further subgroup analyses. Within studies there was large variation in effect sizes between different guideline indicators and between different hospitals. CONCLUSIONS: A&F showed a positive effect on clinical guideline adherence in medical specialist care, with limited heterogeneity in A&F effectiveness across different studies. Notably, this is the first A&F review to document the within-study variation in A&F effectiveness, emphasizing the influence of clinical topics and context. Furthermore, this review highlights the variability in co-interventions used alongside A&F, underscoring challenges in comparing A&F trials. REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42021267983.

Abstract as published, via PubMed.

View on PubMedFull text at the publisherOpen in the app

For healthcare professionals. The summary is generated by AI from the published abstract, and the evidence level is assigned automatically from the study design on the Oxford CEBM hierarchy. Neither is medical advice. Read the full paper before changing practice.