Skip to main content

Microscope-Assisted Tubular Lumbar Discectomy vs Open Microdiscectomy: A Prospective Comparative Study

In brief

Tubular lumbar discectomy cuts operating time by 24 minutes and speeds recovery

In this nonrandomized study, tubular surgery shortened hospital stays by 0.6 days and return to work by 10 days compared with open surgery. Pain and disability scores were better early on, but differences were below thresholds for meaningful improvement and were not significant at 12 months; the results favor faster recovery, not long-term superiority.

Journal
International journal of spine surgery (Q1)
Published
12 November 2026
Study design
Non-randomized / quasi-experimental trial
Evidence level
Level 2, Moderate (CEBM 2b)
Authors
Muhammad Nawaz Khan, Syed Shayan Shah, Ihsan Ullah, Zia Ullah, Sadia Shafique
PMID
43020663
DOI
10.14444/8991

Why clinicians should know about it

  • Picked for Spine Surgery (top studies of the week, 15 November 2026): Prospective comparison of tubular and open lumbar discectomy

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Lumbar disc herniation (LDH) is a leading cause of radiculopathy and disability worldwide. Open microdiscectomy remains the criterion standard, but it requires paraspinal muscle stripping, which may delay recovery. Microscope-assisted tubular discectomy, which combines reusable tubular retractors with a standard operating microscope, is useful in resource-limited settings where endoscopic platforms are unavailable, yet prospective data from such settings are scarce. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether microscope-assisted tubular discectomy is associated with a more favorable perioperative and early recovery profile, with no statistically significant difference in long-term clinical outcomes, compared with open microdiscectomy for single-level LDH. METHODS: In this prospective comparative study, 150 patients with single-level LDH were enrolled at a tertiary care neurosurgical center (January 2020 to December 2024) and allocated on a nonrandomized basis, determined by operative list scheduling and surgeon availability, to tubular (n = 75) or open microdiscectomy (n = 75). After loss to follow-up, 71 and 72 patients, respectively, were analyzed. All procedures in both arms were performed or directly supervised by a single senior neurosurgeon. Primary outcomes were visual analog scale leg and back pain and Oswestry Disability Index at baseline, 2 weeks, and 3, 6, and 12 months. Secondary outcomes included operative time, blood loss, hospital stay, time to ambulation, and return to work among employed patients. Longitudinal primary outcomes were analyzed with linear mixed-effects models (patient as random intercept; group, time, and group by time as fixed effects). Multivariable regression was adjusted for baseline covariates, and a propensity-score-matched sensitivity analysis was performed to further address confounding from nonrandomized allocation. RESULTS: Tubular discectomy was associated with shorter operative time (48.5 vs 72.3 minutes), less blood loss (32.4 vs 78.6 mL), shorter hospital stay (1.2 vs 1.8 days), earlier ambulation (0.8 vs 1.2 days), and faster return to work among employed patients (18.0 vs 28.0 days; n = 60 vs 57; all P < 0.001). Linear mixed-effects models showed significantly lower visual analog scale and Oswestry Disability Index scores in the tubular group at 2 weeks and at 3 and 6 months; between-group differences did not exceed established minimum clinically important difference thresholds, and the difference was not statistically significant at 12 months. Complication (11.3% vs 16.7%, P = 0.39) and recurrence rates were comparable; dural tears occurred in 9.9% vs 4.2% (P = 0.19). A propensity-score-matched sensitivity analysis (58 pairs) reproduced the direction and approximate magnitude of these findings. CONCLUSIONS: Microscope-assisted tubular discectomy offered meaningful perioperative advantages and faster early recovery, with long-term outcomes not significantly different from open microdiscectomy at 12 months. Given the nonrandomized design and the observational nature of the comparison, these findings should be interpreted as evidence of a favorable perioperative profile rather than a demonstration of long-term superiority. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Microscope-assisted tubular discectomy using reusable retractors and a standard operating microscope is a safe and efficient alternative to open microdiscectomy, particularly in resource-constrained environments where endoscopic infrastructure is unavailable.

Abstract as published, via PubMed.

View on PubMedFull text at the publisherOpen in the app

For healthcare professionals. The summary is generated by AI from the published abstract, and the evidence level is assigned automatically from the study design on the Oxford CEBM hierarchy. Neither is medical advice. Read the full paper before changing practice.