Volar Versus Dorsal Approach for Scaphoid Nonunion: A Randomized Controlled Trial of Task-Specific Wrist Kinematics
In brief
Dorsal repair showed 10.5 degrees less task-related wrist extension asymmetry
In this randomized trial, 9 patients who had dorsal repair showed a 1-degree operated-to-healthy wrist extension gap during a phone-handling task, compared with 11.5 degrees after volar repair. The difference was not statistically significant; all fractures united, and patient-rated and standard motion outcomes were similar. Larger studies must test whether the task-specific difference is real and clinically meaningful.
- Journal
- Hand (New York, N.Y.) (Q1)
- Published
- 9 November 2026
- Study design
- Randomized controlled trial
- Evidence level
- Level 1, High (CEBM 1b)
- Authors
- Ahmet Serhat Aydın, Mehmet Demirel, Okyar Altaş, Hayati Durmaz, Ömer Ayık, Halil İbrahim Balcı, et al.
- PMID
- 43001499
- DOI
- 10.1177/15589447261498644
Why clinicians should know about it
- Picked for Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (top studies of the week, 15 November 2026): Randomized hand-surgery comparison of scaphoid nonunion approaches
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The optimal surgical approach for scaphoid nonunion remains debated. This study compared task-specific wrist kinematics following volar versus dorsal reconstruction using wearable inertial sensors, with operated-healthy side difference as the primary endpoint. METHODS: In this single-center prospective randomized controlled trial, 21 patients with waist-type scaphoid nonunion eligible for either approach were randomized in a 1:1 ratio to volar or dorsal reconstruction; 18 patients (9 per group) completed 12-month follow-up and were included in the analysis. Surgical fixation, distal radius bone grafting, and rehabilitation were standardized. The primary outcome was the operated-healthy side difference in peak wrist extension during a simulated phone-handling task at 12 months, measured using wearable inertial measurement units. Secondary outcomes included Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE), scapholunate angle correction, and goniometric wrist motion. RESULTS: All fractures achieved union at a mean follow-up of 12 months. The operated-healthy side difference in peak wrist extension was -11.5° in the volar group and -1.0° in the dorsal group (between-group difference, -10.5°; 95% CI, -22.5° to 1.5°; P = .083), indicating a numerically smaller extension asymmetry in the dorsal group. Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation, radiographic correction, and standard goniometric extension were comparable between groups. Secondary kinematic analyses suggested task-specific differences in other planes of motion. CONCLUSIONS: Both approaches yielded similar union and patient-reported outcomes. The dorsal group demonstrated a numerically smaller extension asymmetry during a functional task, although this between-group difference did not reach statistical significance. Wearable sensor-based assessment may reveal clinically meaningful functional asymmetries not captured by traditional outcome measures. Larger adequately powered studies are needed to determine whether these exploratory differences are reproducible and clinically meaningful. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level I.
Abstract as published, via PubMed.
For healthcare professionals. The summary is generated by AI from the published abstract, and the evidence level is assigned automatically from the study design on the Oxford CEBM hierarchy. Neither is medical advice. Read the full paper before changing practice.